Friday, September 14, 2007

Johannes is already in Madagascar II



Community Conservation

In Tulear I had the opportunity to acquire some first hand theoretical and practical skills about community based conservation by partly attending a workshop held by the WWF and ANGAP (The Malagasy National park Authority). This five day workshop is given by Robert Horwich from Community Conservation Inc. based in Wisconsin, USA.

Horwich suggests a an approach to conservation where the community should not only be actively integrated into the planning, but also in the long term take over key administrative responsibilities. It is pivotal to the success of any conservation project to start on a small scale. If a project is successful it will propagate and neighboring villages will join in voluntarily.

This workshop is aimed for practitioner of NGOs, communities and authorities implementing the Durban Vision (President Ramanafanas promise to increase protected areas in Madagascar to 10 % of the land by 2012).

Beside many practical information, this workshop was an excellent opportunity to network with local practitioners and authorities.

Johannes is already in Madagascar I


Arboretum d’Antsokay

As part of my preparation for this expedition to the spiny forest, I spent some time at the arboretum d’Antsokay. This arboretum is located 13 km out of the city of Tulear. Almost all plants – trees – of the arboretum are native to the spiny forest of the south of Madagascar. Many plants area endemic to this unique habitat, this means they are not to be found anywhere else naturally.

Plants of the south are generally considered as xerophytes, meaning plants of an arid habitat. Famous representatives of the flora of the spiny forests are the generas Adensonia, Aloe, Alluaudia, Didiera, Delonix, Euphorbia, Pachypodium and many more.

The whole family of the Didieraceae was for a long time considered to be endemic to Madagascar. However, new phyllogenetic evidence suggested that the genera Calyptrotheca, Ceraria and Portulacaria from the African continent should be placed as well within the family of Didieraceae, meaning it is no longer an endemic family to the spiny forest of Madagascar.

An other famous tree of Madagascar and the whole African continent is Adensonia ssp. or also more commonly known as baobab. Although most people will be familiar with this tree, few people know that it has its highest diversity in Madagascar, not in Africa or Australia as one might assume. There are 8 species of Adensonia, six are endemic to Madagascar, one to continental Africa and one to Australia. It is now even believed that seeds from Madagascar floated to Africa and Australia and thus Adensonia originates from Madagascar.

By all the beauty of this arboretum, one can not ignore the human impact on the spiny forest. Although the forest looks very intact and carefully managed in the arboretum, coming from Tulear one will pass a lot deforested areas. This has several reason, the mains are charcoal production, construction wood and brick production.

Thursday, August 16, 2007

"Madagascar is sometimes called the Island at the End of the Earth. Even within Madagascar there is an especially far-off place, the extreme south: extreme in its distance, extreme in its parching climate, extreme in the violent reputation of its people... If ever you visit Madagascar, you may well come here. Among its spiny deserts lies a nature reserve called Berenty - a tiny place, but in its own way a microcosm of the world.

LORDS AND LEMURS
Alison Jolly

Thursday, August 9, 2007

Volaré...

Flying to Madagascar has been a regular topic of debate within the group. We thought of alternatives in the beginning such as traveling overland all the down down the East coast of Africa and then taking across the Mozambican channel. You would expect boats to make regular trips from Northern Mozambique to Madagascar, as this is the closest point between the continent and the island. Well, in fact they do not exist, and probably for a good reason. The only boats we had heard off leave from Tanzania to Comoros and from Comoros to Madagascar they sink. At least a high enough proportion so that we decided it was not a good idea. The last option was to take a boat from Djubuti port. Yeah, right. No boats from Africa mainland stopped us from making an alternative trip by boat from Northern Spain to South Africa, which actually we could never arrange either.

We lost a fifth member to the group and our likely fourth member after we lost him because we had to fly. I deeply admire her decision and it made me really wander whether it was not hypocritical of me to do a conservation project in Madagascar contributing to climate change with so much CO2 emitted in the return long-haul flight. It seems one of Madagascar's biggest threat to biodiversity is in fact climate change and so it seems as non-sense to claim conservation but at the same being such part of the problem. Despite the fact that my sole seat in the plane won't make a difference in global terms -and besides the plane will take off with or without me- I do believe that I like everyone else has to make the effort to reduce my personal contribution to climate change. I like to think that if our project somehow prevents trees from being chopped down, this is already a better outcome that not flying at all. We will have to see what happens.

Alternatively we have decided to offset out flights. Out of the several companies that I contacted, eForests based in London offered to sponsor us by offsetting our flights. I hope the offset will be based on supporting clean technology rather than planting trees. I am not convinced by the whole planting trees idea. How can anyone ensure the trees will live long enough so that they breather all the CO2 they are supposed to? Threes may die earlier than expected because of climate change itself, so there is no point in planting them unless climate change can be controlled.

I prefer the money to be invested in projects which make a real reduction in emissions. Improved technology is the obvious example. eForests offer providing energy-efficient light bulbs to low income family, which not only overcomes the economic barrier that sometimes stop people from purchasing such items, but it also serves as a means to make the case for the need to change lifestyles. Other companies focus on developing countries with improved technology and this makes the case for both maintaining the so Western-loved original rain forests and the like as well as providing other benefits for the local population. An interesting example that I have seen is the substitution of traditional stoves which consume a lot of wood for energy-efficient stoves which not only use less wood, but save time that can be employed somewhere else, and perhaps most importantly, help reduce a household's pollution and in turn improves a family's health conditions.

On the other hand, planting trees can make a real difference as tress not only absorb C02, but also maintain a stable watershed, prevent fertile soils from being washed away thus avoiding erosion, and ensure more frequent rainfall.

I wander whether environmental education to reduce one's carbon footprint could also be offered as an offsetting scheme.

Wednesday, August 8, 2007

Madagascar's loss

Madagascar has been one of the last places on Earth to be colonized and sustain a human population. It occurred sometime between A.D. 300 and 800. In evolutionary terms it means that its high biodiversity developed isolated from human kind and has therefore struggled to cope after its arrival. Madagascar species are not as shy and fearful as they should be, and dodo-like experience tells the story of animal populations that collapsed once they were discovered by humans. The most remarkable case is of course the extinction of the giant lemurs in the 17th Century. Africa, the land of big mammals, saw perhaps the most elaborated co-living between humans and nature as species had hundreds of thousands of years to adapt to man's development of technology and learn to fear him. African species also enjoyed low human population densities in most areas maintained through millenia, so they could develop their own niche outside human settlements to ensure evolutionary survival. It is only in recent times that increased urbanization, population explosion due to a dramatic drop in death rates and intensification of land use -for cash exports for example- are undermining the old African eco-balance and putting pressure on current species.

Monday, August 6, 2007

Development, Conservation, or Both?

Out of its more than 220 species of amphibians, only one is found somewhere else outside Madagascar. Alison Jolly , pioneer int the study of the famous lemurs called it "An Archipelago on an Island". Madasgascar is globally known for its high degree of endemic biodiversity. Yet, 90% of its original forests are now totally or partially damaged. Recent studies by the Centre for Applied Biodiversity Science (CABS) indicate that if this rate continues, all of Madagascar's forests will be lost within 40 years (Conservation International 2007), and with them, a large proportion of its endemic plant and animal species.

As part of an increasingly concerned first world about the environmental problems driven by Western style projects, Madagascar has been targeted as an international priority in what concerns biodiversity conservation. In 1999, France, the lead donor, provided $116 million, followed by the World Bank's International Development Association ($73.1 million), the European Union ($22.3 million), and the United States ($20.8). Conservation has been recently a hallmark in the political arena too. Madagascar’s president Mr. Ravalomanana committed to a tripling of protected areas in Madagascar during the African Union summit at Durban in 2003.

So more forests means more biodiveristy. However, it also means less resources for people to use it. With a growth rate of 3% a year (one of the highest in the world), more forest and more people on the same land mass seems a difficult scenario. Should we therefore save the forest or save the people? I don't expect to find an easy answer, but I hope I will find an inspiring one. After all, what has happened to most European pristine ecosystems? Our expedition aims at finding a balance between the forest and the people, not so that we can save either, but so that we can learn and take it back home.